Heads up, parents: New study with important information about the online life of teens

Claire McCarthy, MD
Claire McCarthy, MD, Faculty Editor, Harvard Health Publications

Let’s face it: most parents have no clue what their teens are doing online. According to a new study, even the parents who think they know what’s going on are missing most of it.

For the study, CNN partnered with two researchers — Marion Underwood of the University of Texas and Robert Faris of the University of California, Davis — to study the social media lives of 216 eighth graders from eight middle schools in Georgia, Indiana, New Jersey, New York, Texas, and Virginia. The researchers installed software that monitored what the teens did online for six months (with their permission) and had the teens and their parents fill out questionnaires at the beginning and end. Here are some important highlights of the study that all parents of teens should know:

13-year-olds are “intensely engaged with social media.” This isn’t a big surprise to anyone who has hung out with a 13-year-old recently. About 63% of the youth in the study were on Instagram, 34% were on Twitter, and 20% were on Facebook. On average, they post about four times a week. They also spend much more time online than on social media; most of the time they spend is watching and reading what others are doing online.

FOMO (fear of missing out) is a big reason for being online. Teens see social media as a way to connect with their peers and see what they are doing, and are frequently checking social media. One in five teens checks to be sure that no one is saying anything mean about them, which is sad — and one in three checks to see if friends are doing anything without them. While the most common reason for checking social media is boredom (80%), many teens see social media as the main way to find out what their friends are doing.

There is a dark side to FOMO: the study found that teens who spent a lot of time “lurking” online were more likely to experience distress — from feeling left out, from feeling not popular enough, from feeling upset about things they read, or from conflict online. Because…

Online conflict is common. In the study, 42% of the students reported some form of conflict — usually with a friend — at least once a month. There is also conflict that arises when youth feel they have been socially excluded, and conflict among friends often unfolds online.

Teens view social media as a barometer of popularity. For teens, especially young teens, popularity is very important — and the followers, “likes,” “tags,” and comments can seem like a quantifiable way to measure popularity.

Interestingly, two groups of teens who were more likely to experience distress were those who use social media to try to increase their popularity, and attractive teens who felt they weren’t getting enough recognition via social media.

Parents don’t really know what their children are doing. The paper had some pointed examples of disconnection between what parents said and believed about the online behavior of their children and what was actually happening. The authors wrote, “Parents systematically underestimated how much negative emotion and problematic behavior their children were experiencing, and overestimated how much happiness and fun their teens were having.”

This does not mean that the online experience is mostly negative for youth. On the contrary, most youth reported that it made them feel good about themselves, and that it allowed them to connect with and make new friends and find support.

Really, the online life of teens is simply an extension of their offline life. The themes are all the same. They are just played out in a different space, one that can be both good — and dangerous. That’s why it’s so important that parents be involved. In fact, the study found that when parents were aware of what their children were doing online, their children were less likely to experience distress.

The authors said that they agreed with researcher danah boyd, who wrote in her 2014 book It’s Complicated: The Social Life of Networked Teens:

“What makes the digital street safe is when teens and adults collectively agree to open their eyes and pay attention, communicate and collaboratively negotiate difficult situations. Teens need the freedom to wander the digital street, but they also need to know that caring adults are behind them and supporting them wherever they go. The first step is to turn off the tracking software. Then ask your kids what they do when they are online — and why it’s so important to them.”

Which is remarkably good advice.

Comments:

  1. ReKonnectKids

    Excessive social media or intensive engagement has real potential to cause mental health issues later in adulthood. Not every waking minute needs to be spent online!

  2. Muhammad Naeem ul Fateh

    Things are more worst than this research expressed in this article. Connection is pivotal but this should be face to face more than that the online. Prevalence of online connection over physical contact create complicated psychological effects on a youth brain. Young brain is like a empty plate where you can write whatever you like or what climate we provide.
    More control, social and ethical norms are pivotal and effective engagement of youth will create society to prosper.
    Muhammad Naeem ul Fateh, PhD

  3. Manimaran Ayyavoo

    Time Management to do duties in a planned manner,all work and no play makes every one a dullard, work or studies or whatever profession one engages in, it should be dealt with dedicated determination,involved interest,guiding the tender wonders to engage themselves prioritizing assertively what is for fun and what is for living. Being with them to show the way in a palatable manner will definitely yield Positive results,sticking to the reality,rooted to earth,growing to touch the sky vertically and glowing abreast. Veritas.

  4. Burmese Days

    This article is meaningless. Much of what Dr. McCarthy writes is well-known to parents who still practice common sense, but the rest is meaningless.

    Kids shouldn’t go online because it “makes them feel good about themselves.” Try teaching your kids some skills, then they will have self-esteem for a good reason.

    I don’t let my kids go online much, and never unsupervised. Responsible parents don’t let their kids play with screens much, be they tablets or computers (And never video games!).

    Encourage them to read books and engage in real life activities. We spend too much time living through our devices, and that’s not living.

    • Lilly Potter

      I very much disagree with you. Trying to completely take teen’s lives offline can disconnect them from their peers who organize and express themselves online. Technology is not per se a bad thing for young people, it is just desirable that they communicate openly with their parents. Which should be encouraged and trust built, rather than imposing surveillance on all their activities and robbing them off any freedom to express themselves without having their parents watch.

  5. Scope1

    Stress about exclusion, anxiety about who doesn’t like them, worry about what others think of them, boredom…these are long-standing issues among teens and they certainly predate social media. But a generation *is* evolving with different approaches to these older symptoms. The further research question, and a good longitudinal study, would be to ask how — or to what extent — might teens’ social media behaviors and their motivating factors carry on into adulthood. The constant checking of one’s devices not only inhibits *real* social interactions but it severely impedes mental focus and fractures work flow.