Michael Craig Miller, M.D.

Nighttime overeating can throw weight and health out of sync

As evening turns to night, I often find myself looking for a snack. Sometimes the impulse comes from a bit of hunger, but I’m just as likely to make my way to the kitchen without thinking. I know that I’m not alone in this satisfying but potentially problematic habit.

The occasional late-night snack is nothing to worry about. But nightly bingeing merits a closer look. Experts may debate whether nocturnal overeating needs its own diagnostic category, but they don’t debate the significance of the problem.

As described in “Out of Sync,” an article in the current issue of The Scientist, eating at the wrong time can throw off the body’s metabolic cycles, leading to weight gain and other problems. According to the article, new research continues to “add to the growing recognition that our metabolisms are primed by the circadian machinery written in our genes, and that discord between the two can wreak havoc on our systems.”

Two types of nighttime eating disorders

Sleep-related eating disorder is a highly-publicized malady, though it’s not clear how common it is. People with this problem eat while sleepwalking, or while in a twilight state between sleep and wakefulness. They generally aren’t conscious of what they’re doing, so they may wake up to find the bed littered with candy wrappers — with no memory of consuming the candy. Dr. Brandon R. Peters, a sleep medicine expert affiliated with the Stanford Center for Sleep Sciences and Medicine, described a case of sleep-related eating disorder last month on The Huffington Post.

A better-documented problem is night eating syndrome, in which people do the majority of their eating late at night. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that by 6 p.m., people with night eating syndrome consumed a little more than a third of their daily calories, while a control group had consumed almost three-quarters. Between 8 p.m. and 6 a.m., however, the night eaters consumed 56% of daily calories, while controls consumed only 15%.

Night eating syndrome may affect 1 or 2 out of 100 people in the general population. Dr. Albert J. Stunkard, a psychiatrist at the University of Pennsylvania, first described the disorder in the 1950s. Researchers have recently explored its link to weight gain. The problem affects anywhere from 9% to 14% of people seeking treatment at obesity clinics, and as many as 27% of severely obese people.

Night eating syndrome also occurs in people who are treated in mental health clinics. In one study of psychiatric outpatients in Pennsylvania and Minnesota, 12% had night eating syndrome. Night eaters in this study were also much more likely than other individuals to have an addiction problem. Other research indicates that people with night eating syndrome tend to suffer from a distinct form of depression. In contrast to the usual pattern where depression is more pronounced in the early part of the day, night eaters tend to become more depressed during the evening.

It’s not clear what causes night eating syndrome and why it is associated with depression or addiction. One theory is that night eating syndrome involves a disruption in the hormones that regulate sleep, appetite, or mood. Because late-night snacking usually involves carbohydrate-rich “comfort” foods, this theory holds that night eating syndrome is a form of self-medication.

Breaking the cycle

Sleeping and eating are almost certainly connected, given the link between lack of sleep and weight gain. So getting plenty of sleep may be a helpful substitute for nighttime trips to the refrigerator. Until more is known about night eating syndrome, it’s probably best to take a broad approach to stopping it.

  • See your doctor for a complete health evaluation.
  • An evaluation by a mental health professional is a good idea to determine whether or not another mental disorder could be contributing to the eating problem. If so, treating that underlying mental health problem, such as depression or anxiety, may improve eating patterns and the chances of getting to sleep earlier.
  • See a dietitian about how to better pace meals throughout the day, which may help break the cycle of late-night eating.
  • Case reports indicate that some people can improve their eating patterns by being mindful of the problem and by trying to identify its triggers.
  • The type of talk therapy known as cognitive behavioral therapy may help. Stress-reduction techniques may help avert trips to the refrigerator.
  • Preliminary studies indicate that the anticonvulsant topiramate (Topamax) or a selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRI) antidepressant such as sertraline (Zoloft) may also work.

An earlier version of this article appeared on InteliHealth.com

Comments:

  1. Jane McKarthy

    I admit that i am a night eater as well…and unfortunately i do it in daily basis and a lot too!
    The trick is also with what you are eating…Yogurt for example is very light and healthy

  2. Charity

    Thank-you for sharing such an interesting post–I had never heard of Nighttime Eating Syndrome. However, I would like to see more studies examining the link between nighttime eating with weight gain. It seems to me, that if an individual is maintaining the same level of exercise and eating the same general amount of calories per day, then it wouldn’t matter what time of day those calories are being consumed in order to maintain the same weight. This was an interesting topic, worthy of more investigations.

  3. Predivita

    Not long ago there was an article about that it doesn’t matter when you eat but it’s all about what you eat during a day/night. Strange that things change so quickly.. There’s a lot to be looked into. Predivita proteine dieet

  4. fat burning

    thanks for sharing this value article.I think all of us have this bad habit to eat late in the night i hope to change it .

    thanks lot

  5. Sumant Kaul

    Great Information. Thanks for sharing the reasons for over weight.

  6. boxing exercises

    When I got busy and overloaded with my jobs, so many thing in mind to be clear. subconsciously, I took foods more than usual since I felt I couldn’t finish all that jobs if my stomach empty :D
    Lately, I am trying to take more fruits in the night to control my healthy eating.
    Thanks :)

  7. obat kuat

    thanks for the information, I so understand it
    regards healthy hehehe

  8. Richard Blaine

    I used to be a major night time eater and it took me years to stop eating late at night! It was like I wasn’t hungry between the times of 6 to 9 pm. I would go to bed and end up getting up at 3am and I would go eat. I went from 152lbs out of college wrestling to 211lbs in a year and then it took me 2yrs to lose the weight correctly and to stop eating at night. I found it was a nutritional matter and once I realigned my dietary habits I stopped eating late at night. It was a blood sugar complication. Great article!

  9. Rakesh Gupta

    I appreciate from this post & I know that 2 People those that square measure regular night eaters. They even have issues with symptom and acid reflux.

  10. Marc

    I know two people that are regular night eaters. They also have problems with heartburn and acid reflux.

    • Xiaoyong tan

      I love to eat a lot at night, now I understand it is not good for health at all. Thank you so much for your information. I must be careful from now. it is very helpful blogs.