Ann MacDonald

How to become a better perfectionist

I often think of the well-known expression “perfect is the enemy of good” when I am endlessly rewriting an article to make it better (when it is already good enough) and in the process just make or even miss a deadline. But this old saying also reflects the dark view many people have of perfectionism. As a personality trait, it is seen as obsessive and at times pathological. People who are perfectionists may become so focused on setting a high standard for themselves that they live their lives as if graded constantly on a report card.

But perfectionism has a bright side, too. Desirable aspects of this personality trait include conscientiousness, endurance, satisfaction with life, and the ability to cope with adversity. This helps explain why some perfectionists become corporate leaders, skilled surgeons, or Olympic champions.

Dr. Jeff Szymanski, a clinical instructor of psychology at Harvard Medical School and executive director of the International OCD Foundation, believes it is possible to become a better perfectionist—by building on the strengths of this quality and learning to minimize its drawbacks. In his new book, The Perfectionist’s Handbook, he discusses this theory in greater detail and provides exercises people can try at home.

I recently talked with Dr. Szymanski about his book. He says a key step in becoming a better perfectionist is to learn how to turn mistakes into strategic experiments.

“Perfectionism is a phobia of making mistakes,” Dr. Szymanski says. “Perfectionists are hard on themselves, very self-critical. But in beating themselves up, they end up demoralizing themselves.”

In the video that accompanies this post, Dr. Szymanski outlines a process for turning mistakes into strategic experiments. “The core of all perfectionism is the intention to do something well,” Dr. Szymanski says. “The challenge is to think about doing it differently.”

But that is often where he encounters resistance to change. “As soon as I talk with someone who is a perfectionist about changing the way they do something, the defenses go up,” says Dr. Szymanski. “What I learned is that they thought I was telling them to lower the bar and be average. But that isn’t what I’m saying. The intention to do well isn’t the problem. What I’m challenging is the strategies that people use to achieve their goals.”

Suppose someone wants to become a better writer. The intention is laudable. But a perfectionist may approach this goal by editing copy excessively, or ruminating about a sentence that isn’t working before moving on to the next. These counterproductive strategies lead to missed deadlines and loss of confidence. Many perfectionists then dwell on their mistakes and failure to accomplish their goal.

As an alternative, Dr. Szymanski suggests stepping back from the task—in this case, writing—in order to come up with different ways to accomplish it. To return to the example above, the individual could try writing for 10 minutes without editing. By using this strategy, Dr. Szymanski says, people often find that their writing becomes better and smoother than when they stop and pick at it along the way.

And if one option doesn’t work, try another. Focus less on the mistake than on finding a solution. “Healthy perfectionists are problem solvers,” Dr. Szymanski says. “They make the most of their mistakes.”

For more information about Harvard Health Publications’ new book, The Perfectionist’s Handbook, including ordering information, see www.health.harvard.edu/perfectionist.

 Szymanski-Perfectionist

Comments:

  1. Heather Smith

    I do appreciate the topic but i have to disagree for the people who wants to be a perfectionist. I think that being a perfectionist will not make you happy. Maybe for some people but not me. Thanks for posting this.

  2. Herbert Peters

    Perfectionism as an approach to problem solving and quality?
    A perfectionist is one who endeavours to give more than he has. Whereas a business man is one who competes by giving slightly more than what market/others give. While perfectionists like Rudolf Diesel, or Ernst Hemmingway had to commit suicide; businessmen becomes the great guys on earth. So it makes sense to classify perfectionism as pathology?
    Now to strategy as the key to aid to perfectionism vs Perfectionism as an approach to solving problem. The perfectionist’s goals have to come from the problem he is aiming to solve or perfectionism is the way to better quality.
    For writers, writing by editing or rewriting existing works is one approach or strategy to succeed. The new writer has to be a perfectionist who employs better strategies. Imagine all the learning and changes that can come around in writing and media. Other industries are very good at this approach.

  3. Medical Health Shaman

    i wanna buy this book? is it sold via amazon.com?