Recent Blog Articles

Harvard Health Blog

For early breast cancer, lumpectomy is at least as good as mastectomy

Published: January 29, 2013
  • Author: Howard LeWine, M.D.,


As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review or update on all articles. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.


louis vuitton imitation handbags
March 16, 2013

$17.49 directly from Additional lanyards can be purchased for $5.95 (basic cotton/rayon blend) or $9.25 (pure cotton or undyed cotton).Follow Chewelry and louis vuitton imitation handbags

Man and van Norwich
March 11, 2013

I think that with the amount of us affected by cancer these days education about how to deal with the emotional side is very important. I can say that I’m an expert but I think that most women would opt for the mastectomy as they believe if they don’t have a breast they are less likely to have a recurrence of the cancer. The only reason for this is you are put in a position where you have to make a choice and you have no knowledge of the possible outcomes so the choice is made from general logic rather than an educated choice. I just wonder how many lives could be saved if we educated some of these women.

piano removals
March 06, 2013

Why do women wanted to remove their entire breast when they are diagnosed with early cancer stage? Though the recurrences is 90+% sure.

February 05, 2013

I had a lumpectomy last May. That’s what I chose vs a masectomy. It’s what I felt more comfy with and I went on to do chemo (4 cycles) and radiation (33 treatments). There is no history of breast cancer-that I know of- in my family. Good to have a big support system!! I think positive thoughts helps a lot!

January 31, 2013

Very useful article, I read about breast cancer in one forum, it is dangerous.

Boro Petric
January 31, 2013

Which is more prone in breast cancer? If i am not mistaken one of the best natural cancer killer is by just drinking a carrot.Right?


Wagner Oral Surgery
January 30, 2013

I can only imagine how hard that would be to make the choice between the two. This was really good information, sounds like it was very thorough research.

January 29, 2013

For a study like this, giving more information on the family history will throw more light on my options. I am currently deciding between these 2 options and it’s really difficult. A friend of mine with early stage breast cancer opted for mastectomy because her mom and sister did not survive. My mom survives, does it mean the cancer cell is our family is less aggressive, hence I should opt for lumpectomy?

February 08, 2013

As the article states, much of the decision depends on your point of view. Do what is comfortable for you, depending on where you live and the availability of your treatments. I chose lumpectomy and traveled 100 miles for my surgery. My surgeon does Mammoplasty and Oncoplasty, using plastic surgery techniques, which result in a wonderful cosmetic outcome.

I also had IORT(Intra-operative radiation) at the time of surgery, which shortens the treatments afterward to 3 weeks, rather than 6 weeks (15 treatments, as opposed to 30). Take your time, research using reliable sources on the internet or otherwise. Ask lots of questions! If you don’t get answers, try another source. You are important and this is an important decision for you!

Commenting has been closed for this post.