Gov. Christie’s weight-loss surgery: a good idea for health

Howard LeWine, M.D.

Chief Medical Editor, Harvard Health Publishing

New Jersey Governor Chris Christie’s revelation yesterday that he had secretly undergone weight-loss surgery back in February shouldn’t come as a big surprise. He has been publicly (and privately) struggling with his weight for years and fits the profile of a good candidate for this kind of operation.

Although weight-loss surgery, also known as bariatric surgery, should be considered a last resort when diet and exercise don’t work, it can do some amazing things. Among people who are severely overweight, it can yield a 25% to 35% weight loss within two years. In many people who undergo the surgery, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, and the disruptive and potentially harmful snoring pattern known as sleep apnea disappear. It can also improve a number of other health problems, ranging from arthritis and heartburn to infertility and incontinence.

Good candidates

In general, weight-loss surgery is appropriate for people with a body mass index (BMI) of 40 or higher, as well as for those with a BMI of 35 to 39.9 and a severe, treatment-resistant medical condition such as diabetes, heart disease, and sleep apnea.

Much of the speculation about Christie’s surgery was whether he did it for political reasons or concerns about his future health. But there shouldn’t be any speculation about whether he was a good candidate for it. While the Governor never made public his exact weight, the estimate is over 300 pounds. At just under 6 feet tall, that gives him a body mass index of at least 41. Christie also acknowledged trying to lose weight many times, using different weight loss programs. He had some initial success. But like most obese people, he regained all the lost pounds and more.

Even if Christie’s claims of otherwise being in good health are correct, he was at high risk of developing problems directly related to his weight. I believe his choice was a good one for his health.

Types of weight-loss surgery

Gastric banding2Christie underwent laparoscopic gastric banding, also known as lap banding. There are also two other types of weight-loss surgery.

Gastric banding is done laparoscopically, meaning through small holes made in the abdomen. The surgeon wraps an adjustable silicone band about two inches in diameter around the upper part of the stomach. This creates a small pouch with a narrow opening that empties into the rest of the stomach. The small size of the upper stomach make a person feel full much sooner than before. Depending on the person’s rate of desired weight loss and how he or she feels, the band can be easily tightened or loosened as needed by injecting or withdrawing sterile salt water saline through a port implanted just under the skin. Compared with gastric bypass, the surgery is simpler and has a lower risk of complications immediately following the operation.

Gastric_bypass2Gastric bypass, also known as the Roux-en-Y procedure, shrinks the size of the stomach by more than 90%. This makes a person feel full after eating very small amounts of food. In addition, the body absorbs fewer calories because food bypasses most of the stomach and upper small intestine. The operation is done through an incision made in the abdomen or laparoscopically. The surgeon converts the upper part of the stomach into a small pouch about the size of an egg. The small intestine is then cut. One end is connected to the stomach pouch and the other is reattached to the small intestine, creating a Y shape. This allows food to bypass most of the stomach and the upper part of the small intestine, although both continue to produce the gastric juices, enzymes, and other secretions needed for digestion. These drain into the intestine and mix with food at the crook of the Y. Gastric bypass surgery is not reversible.

Gastric sleeve2The gastric sleeve technique transforms the stomach into a small, narrow tube by removing the curved side of the organ creates a small pouch using the side of the stomach rather than the bottom. One advantage is that no rearrangement of the intestines is needed. The vertical pouch the sleeve procedure creates is less prone to stretching compared to the pouch left by a gastric bypass. Like gastric bypass, the gastric sleeve technique is not reversible.

After surgery

For the first few months after surgery, appetite is usually turned down. Eating too quickly or too much overfills the stomach pouch. That can cause vomiting or pain in the chest and upper abdomen. After a high-carbohydrate meal, a person who has had gastric bypass surgery may suffer from “dumping syndrome,” a reaction that causes flushing, sweating, severe fatigue, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and intestinal gas. To prevent nutritional deficits, it’s also a good idea to take vitamins (especially vitamins B12 and D) and minerals (especially calcium and iron).

If you are considering weight loss surgery, realize that you must commit to a life-long change in the way you eat. Surgery without lifestyle change will either make you miserable or not result in successful weight reduction. Likely both.

Related Information: Lose Weight and Keep It Off


  1. Just wonder what is the correlation beetween colesterol and salted egg?,as farI know the nutritionof alted egg is notasmuch as the colesterol needs inour body. So I assume that salted egg is not oneof the cause ofthe colesterol in our body.

  2. pgeorge9500

    Defiantly gradual fat burning capacity is among the most greatest take into account bodyweight achieve. You can find normal as well as herbal strategies to enhance this particular though along with such things as.

  3. mike

    If you are struggling to lose a few pounds then don’t consider yourself alone. Weight loss industry has been keen on providing us all kinds of weight loss products however it is difficult to determine if they actually provide any benefits or are they really healthy

  4. Turnstiles

    I think the trick here is to not make everything colourful. Although some of these get away with it.

  5. evolv health

    Yes this is true that slow metabolism is probably the biggest factor in weight gain. There are natural and herbal ways to increase this though with things like

  6. Rakesh Narang

    These surgeries should really be the last option, because with proper motivation and diet, one can achieve some primitive weight loss, which can then be turned into more substation results.

    My family suggested me to go for surgery but I decided to do it naturally, I am on a weight loss mission.

  7. Ohh! Ma questo è un bel post!

  8. Hola a todos, he venido aquí en busca de respuestas, No sabes bien cómo hacer esto, así que voy a hacer aquí. ahora yo uso 4 herramientas para hacer este trabajo y me parece estar repitiendo la información a la siguiente herramienta para cada nuevo cliente. He estado buscando esta herramienta por un tiempo ahora y no he encontrado uno que funcione, por favor hágamelo saber si uno está ahí fuera.

  9. Mark

    There are so many people that can benefit from this type of weight loss and it is by no means extreme, if it means the difference between life and death. I am all for it. I had an aunty who passed away a couple years ago at the age of 41 due to obesity. Had someone had stepped in and assisted and offered the choice of surgery to fix her obesity problem, she might still be here today.

  10. Tanya R. Eller

    Surgery might be a good idea if you try all natural weight loss schemes but none worked out. It is still important to seek help from an expert with regards to this matter.


    I like this acute approach to lose weight! Fast as you like!

  12. BD Dale

    I’ve seen patients have this surgery and arms, legs etc. look worse than before with ‘flab’. What advances in this area mitigate this?

  13. OpiePride

    This was interesting but I think weight loss surgery in most cases should be used when it’s a life a death matter

  14. Harry

    definitely the last resort, I really have a fear of surgery. I think I’ll try my best to exercise rather than get a surgery, it scares the hell out of me. But many people now are really courageous undergoing surgery for beautification. So if they are not afraid and they fit in the qualification, why not. it’s really a good resort if you don’t have the phobia 🙂

  15. tokoobat

    Good article, but I don’t agree with weight loss surgery. There are many ways, how to loose weight naturally.

    • Natural green cleanse

      Yes, i am agree with you that surgery is the not only way to weight loss You can lose weight by doing exercise and by following healthy chart but is much time consuming and hectic work and second way is by taking weight loss supplements like Natural green cleanse that require less physical efforts to lose the weight.


    Good article, but I don’t agree with weight loss surgery. There are many ways, how to loose weight naturally.

  17. Das war wirklich eine aufschlussreiche Stück Arbeit. Die ad libitum Liste, die Sie organisch produziert hat sicherlich mir Inspiration weiterhin bewundern die Tatsache, dass Sie in der Lage, Material, die wirklich spiegelt die Anordnung eines einzelnen bewusst sind.

  18. Bethany Weathers

    Thanks for all your comments. This means it was all organic traffic for this Hub and I did not even have to write about current events like SOPA and how blog commenting has seen a massive increase because of the stop online piracy act

  19. Trey Bronson

    I love paleo recipe book and have been using it for me and my family for over a year now and I use the book almost everyday because I absolutely love the recipes that are in it.The book is so detailed and trustworthy that I’d recommend it to anyone.I made some of the desserts for my kids and they ask me to make them everyday when they get home from school.There is healthy recipes for diets and an 8 week plan to help you eat better.There is so much information that I would recommend it to anyone because the foods that I get to make from the recipes that are given in the book taste so amazing.If anyone wants to find out more you should definitely check this site out.

  20. John Claire

    Great post! The fact that you means someone is reading and liking it! Congrats!That’s great advice.

  21. weight loss programs

    Smart Eating And Weight LossThe kilos have piled up; the actual pants are getting as well tight. It is about time to start losing off the extra weight. Planning starting from the beginning makes it easier to achieve in your weight loss plans.Keep track of what you eat along with the type of exercise you do every single day. Write every thing down in your record. This gets things prepared and you will be better encouraged to continue on.Cooking your personal meals let you have total control over what to put into your body. No more extra oily, salty or sweet food coming from cafes and eating places to tempt as well as make you stray out of your diet. Get some good publications promoting healthy weight reduction recipes, some basic cooking equipment and you are well on your way in order to healthy cooking. There’s a chance you’re pleasantly surprised at the final results.When shopping for groceries, make sure you check the calories count number and list of elements listed on the food packages. Do not be misled by simply advertisements such as normal, sugar-free and non-fried. Look at the okay prints. Every small bit counts towards unwanted weight loss goals.Eat smaller portions at each meal. Spend money on smaller size discs to make sure you are not influenced to eat more. Much less food on a greater plate might give you the impression that you are not having enough and find yourself taking more meals. Just make sure you are possessing well-balanced meals, even though modest amounts.The occasional deviation from the diet is no big problem. Being too rigid might lead to stress and this is not good for your weight reduction plans. You might get thus frustrated and just give up. Stress can also result in binge eating.Sticking towards the same old food day time in and day trip can be boring along with uninspiring. Try healthy food from around the globe right at home. Some of them can be easy to cook in your home kitchen.Eating your main food in front of the TV, operate table or display screen is a typical bad habit among many of us. It is difficult to be ingesting healthily this way and also besides it is bad for your digestion. In the event you must be munching on some food while operating, munch on carrot stays instead.Poor food choices, bad snacks and a lot of fast and prepared food not only result in an expanding waistline but also clogged arteries. Taking control of the way you eat can lead to beneficial weight loss and a balanced body.

  22. Geoff Lord

    I just read where a guy in the UK had a gastric Sleeve surgery done in France and lost Over 92.6 Lbs in less than three Months. Is this a typical Loss
    Geoff Lord

  23. Saul

    My name is Saul, I was able to beat opiate addiction and have 8 years clean now. If you or anyone needs help you can call me or text me anytime. (561)-706-6236

  24. Weight Loss Surgery Types

    This is really good information on weight loss surgery. This guidelines are helpful to lots of people. But still people not aware about the side effect of over weight. Bariatric surgery are the final option to loose weight for some people.But deciding on a particular surgical method will need a lot of thought and also discussion with the surgeon.

  25. William

    weight loss surgeries are boon for obese people..even i was overweight and now i am healthy since got treated from fortisbariatricsurgery[dot]com

  26. weight loss

    this article teach about different ways to loss weight. The first method is exercise, and surgery. thanks for your useful information…

  27. Gastric sleeve surgery

    Gastric sleeve surgery, is one of the method we choose when its very difficult , or we dont have any other option left, but after surgery also we need to take care alot.

  28. Will

    I think the media needs to leave Christie alone. Whose business is it anyway?

    Now, with that said, my ex girlfriend had the same type of surgery and although it worked for her, I still feel that any weight loss solution that does not include surgery is a better option. A cleanse diet, or something like that can help people lose weight fast too.

  29. gold coast removalist

    I want my wife to have to this to lose her weight. Her metabolism is so slow and she’s getting fatter everyday.

Commenting has been closed for this post.