What is the problem, and who says

What is the problem, and who says?

Published: March, 2014

In deciding how to evaluate the problems of their clients and patients, therapists inevitably rely largely on what they say about themselves in interviews, on questionnaires, and in standard psychological tests. But we don't always know ourselves, or see ourselves as others see us. And our feeling, thinking, and behavior change with the time, the place, the situation, and the company. So it's important to study how well reports agree or disagree when they come from different people in different settings.

It's easiest to get reports from others about children because adults usually bring them for evaluation and treatment. Meta-analyses (pooled statistical analyses) of many studies show that children's ratings of their own problems are correlated poorly with ratings by their parents and other adults in their lives. But the adults don't agree with one another, either — at least not when they encounter children in different contexts, such as home, school, therapy, or a research lab. Adults who play similar roles in the child's life — as parents, teachers, mental health workers, or research observers — are much more likely to agree about the nature of the child's problems, although even then their agreement is imperfect.

To continue reading this article, you must log in.
  • Research health conditions
  • Check your symptoms
  • Prepare for a doctor's visit or test
  • Find the best treatments and procedures for you
  • Explore options for better nutrition and exercise

New subscriptions to Harvard Health Online are temporarily unavailable. Click the button below to learn about our other subscription offers.

Learn More »