Dietary supplement safety

Image: Thinkstock

Published: May, 2014

You've heard all the warnings about dietary supplements. Here are a few that men should use with caution or avoid.

Americans spend more than $32 billion on 85,000 different dietary supplements every year. These products contain various combinations of vitamins, minerals, herbal extracts, and other substances. The manufacturers claim that their products enhance health, but the scientific evidence ranges from slim to none in most cases. People still perceive dietary supplements as inherently harmless, but that's not always true.

"A lot of people are spending unnecessary sums for things that in most cases will do nothing," says Dr. Pieter Cohen, a dietary supplement safety researcher and assistant professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School. "If they buy something from the wrong people, it could do a lot worse than do nothing; it could be dangerous because it might be spiked with actual pharmaceuticals."

Dr. Cohen urges men who use dietary supplements to do it openly. "I would just recommend that guys call their doctors and ask, 'Would you prescribe this to me?'" he says. "Your doctor needs to know what you are taking." That is especially important if you are already on multiple prescriptions, since dietary supplements interact harmfully with certain prescription drugs.

Vitamins and minerals

Some vitamins could be harmful if taken in excessive amounts, meaning above the small Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDAs) required for good health. Here are two to avoid:

Vitamin E: In research, vitamin E has largely failed the test as a heart-health booster. In fact, in one large clinical trial, people who took 400 international units (IU) were more likely to have heart problems compared with those who didn't take vitamin E. The Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT) found that men who took daily supplemental vitamin E were at greater risk of prostate cancer.

Vitamin A: Taking vitamin A supplements can raise blood levels of retinol, which in some research is associated with a greater chance of hip fractures. The link isn't proven to be cause-and-effect, but there is not any strong evidence that vitamin A supplements help you, either. Why take the risk?

"Unless your doctor says you should be taking a vitamin or mineral supplement—be it calcium, iron, or others—don't worry about it," Dr. Cohen says. "Just eat a well-balanced healthy diet and stay away from supplements."

Herbal hazards

In a study of 3,000 adults middle-aged and older, one in 25 (4%) was found to be taking prescription drugs and dietary supplements that could interact harmfully. The supplements can also cause side effects on their own. "You really never know what's in a supplement or if it will interact with the other medications you are already taking," Dr. Cohen says. Here are some Dr. Cohen warns against:

St. John's wort: St. John's wort is often pitched as an herbal remedy for depression, anxiety, fatigue, and sleeplessness. However, it can have a range of bad side effects. These include dry mouth, dizziness, stomach or intestinal discomfort, fatigue, and headache. St. John's wort can alter blood levels of prescription drugs by speeding up or slowing down their metabolism. In several documented cases, the herb interfered with immune-suppressing drugs people were taking to prevent organ transplant rejection.

Blood-thinning herbs: Ginkgo biloba and vitamin E can thin the blood. This could be risky if you are already taking a blood thinner, like warfarin (Coumadin), to prevent clots. "The number of herbal ingredients that interact with warfarin are endless," Dr. Cohen says. "Make sure you tell your doctor or pharmacist—whomever is managing your warfarin—what you are taking."

Supplement quality

The FDA does not require dietary supplements to be tested before marketing to prove they are safe and they work, as is the case with prescription drugs. As a result, products may contain unlisted ingredients and contaminants; some products have tested positive for prescription drugs not listed on the label. One thing you can do is make sure the product is certified by the United States Pharmacopeia or NSF International, which independently assess supplement ingredients.

What supplements can you trust?

If you want to know what's really in your supplements, look for those that have been tested by the following independent nongovernmental organizations:

United States Pharmacopeia. A supplement manufacturer can submit its products for analysis by USP to verify its ingredients' identity, strength, quality, and purity. Look for the "USP verified mark" on the product.

NSF International. This organization also tests dietary supplements. The NSF stamp on a dietary supplement product means it was tested for quality and safety.

As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review or update on all articles. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.