Recent Blog Articles
If cannabis becomes a problem: How to manage withdrawal
Corneal transplants becoming more common
An emerging treatment option for men on active surveillance
Gun violence: A long-lasting toll on children and teens
Adult female acne: Why it happens and the emotional toll
Talking to your doctor about your LGBTQ+ sex life
Untangling grief: Living beyond a great loss
Thunderstorm asthma: Bad weather, allergies, and asthma attacks
Heart problems and the heat: What to know and do
I’m too young to have Alzheimer’s disease or dementia, right?
Many seniors get unnecessary and potentially harmful cancer tests
- By Howard E. LeWine, MD, Chief Medical Editor, Harvard Health Publishing
About the Author
Howard E. LeWine, MD, Chief Medical Editor, Harvard Health Publishing
As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review or update on all articles.
No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.
Over-diagnosis and unnecessary testing could just be due to a shot gun approach that many clinicians follow in their daily practice.
The purpose of screening is prevention. Doctors should only recommend, but if patients refuse, they should not be scared into doing it nor should doctors insist until they bend their patients’ will.
Also, seniors have to make sure they tell their doctors if they are taking PSA lowering medications such as Flomax, Finasteride or Avodart when they get a blood test or prostate cancer screening. These medications can affect PSA test results.
Very very nice post.I am agree with this post.The seniors has more experience.But sometimes people scary to test screening cancer, they afraid of the result if the result is unwanted.Thanks a lot for sharing this post.
I think it goes beyond seniors, it’s an epedemic in America and the direct outcome of technology in the medical field. Our orthodox medicine is broken, we over treat with expensive procedures because doctors get paid extra to push these machines on patients. The entire system is broken and it starts with our government being controlled by corporations.
As an architect I’ve done a major research project on medical facilities and why American health is so poor, all I have to say is follow the money. And look at the pharmecutical companies. We are the only country who allows pharmecutical company’s to advertise to the general population. We are a dependent society folks
Is it surprising that a revenue stream that benefits providers is overused. Physicians see great profit in $ceening test greatly overestimate benefit : consistently minimize damage caused …perhaps in future post you can address such well thought out ideas as beta blockers before surgery…Really about a large amount of the medical cost is for ……..
My mother developed breast cancer at 80, was treated and lived happily to 93. My doctor agrees that at 81 I should continue mammograms every two years. I am healthy, excercise and eat sensibly. I lead a full active life and that is due to a knee replacement I had 3 years ago.
C Hendershott (Aug. 21) tells it like it is; the bureaucrats think old people should suffer and die, and that they don’t deserve a decent quality of life just because they are elderly.
Well, of course if you don’t test people (and old folks are still people…), there will be fewer diagnoses and fewer treatments –expensive or cheap. Want to save money from grammy’s estate, keep her away from all doctors, tests, and treatments. Wouldn’t want her to enjoy her old age by having her knees replaced…. She would only use them for ten years anyway.
Never mind that older people are living independently and well for more years as time goes on. Cut off treatment at 65 anyway. The bureaucrats and bean counters love it.
Don’t want a baby that is going to need time and attention? Have an abortion…..fast, convenient, efficient. Got a mother or grandmother that is inconvenient? Take away medical care now or pass a rule against looking for health problems that are treatable. If you don’t look, you won’t find any. Problem solved.
Just remember, someday, if you are lucky, you too may live long enough to enjoy a long life.
My 89-year-old mother-in-law had a mammogram at the insistance of her doctor. I think this is almost malpractice.
I agree even worst running test like bone density test on terminal patients.
But sometimes people scary to test screening cancer, they afraid of the result if the result is unwanted.
Unfortunately, it isn’t just “senior” members that often get unnecessary cancer screening tests. It’s a general occurrence, mostly because of significant overdiagnosis. As long as the reigning theories of cancer development are steeped heavily in medical dogma instead of sound science (discussed in Rolf Hefti’s “The Mammogram Myth”), this trend of harm infliction continues unabated.
Commenting has been closed for this post.
Free Healthbeat Signup
Get the latest in health news delivered to your inbox!