Many babies and toddlers use mobile devices every day

Claire McCarthy, MD

Senior Faculty Editor, Harvard Health Publishing

This likely isn’t a surprise to anyone who has been paying attention to the world around them, but a study just published in the journal Pediatrics shows that 44% of children under the age of 1 use mobile devices every day. By the age of 2, that jumps to 77%.

By age 4, half of the children in the study had their own TV — and three-quarters had their own mobile device. And these weren’t rich kids, either; the study was done at an urban, low-income practice in Philadelphia.

When the researchers asked parents about different situations where they let their children use the devices, here’s what they said:

  • 70% let the children use them so that they could do chores
  • 65% used them to keep their child calm in a public place
  • 58% used them while running errands
  • 29% used them to put their child to sleep

Now, as a parent, I totally see how having a smartphone can make all the difference when you are unexpectedly stuck in a boring place with a child who needs to be still and quiet. And it’s entirely possible that some of these kids are doing educational activities on their devices that will help them learn, or using Skype or FaceTime with a friend or relative.

But still, this is worrisome. As Dr. Dmitri Christakis, a pediatrician at the University of Washington who researches the effect of media on young children, said in a recent New York Times article, “Children need laps more than apps.” We’ve all been in situations where people are interacting with their phones and not each other. Dr. Jenny Radesky did a study where she watched families in fast food restaurants and found an unsettling number of parents paying more attention to their phone than their child. Interaction with adults is crucial for the brain development of children — and for building strong relationships. Interacting with devices simply can’t replace it.

When my children were young, if we were going anywhere they might need to be quiet or patient, I was always ready — with books, small toys, crayons and paper, and some games to play (I Spy, Guess What I’m Thinking, etc.) I don’t see too many parents doing this anymore. What I see is parents handing their child a tablet or a smartphone.

Only time will tell what effects this will have on children; we will need years to understand if or how it affects their brains and their relationships. While we wait, we should try to do what we know works well for both. So, parents — along with the smartphone, pack some crayons. And consider, before you turn on the iPad, putting your child in your lap and playing I Spy.

Related Information: Harvard Health Letter


  1. Emma Alison

    I think parents should avoid the contact of mobile devices with their babies as it can harm their mental development and growth. They would rather insist them to play with other soft toys. I personally provide only stuffed toys to my 6 years old daughter.

  2. Michael

    This is so true. imagine a Granpa of 110 years old playing xbox with his spouse. Thanks a lot for this post. its really informative. Its obvious we are about to see a greater than Steve Jobs, Apple, Mac facebook.
    Guys your opinions on this topic would be greatly valued. Please take some time out to share with us your thoughts.

  3. Angela Ursery

    Thanks for this post. I’ve noticed the trend myself (though not among kids under 2–yikes!), and find it tremendously unsettling.
    This is similar to ignoring children (or telling them not to disturb or even speak to adults, unless spoken to), a trend among certain families–including my own–when I grew up. Fortunately, I’d learned how to read at an early age, but I do think that practice hindered my social skill development.
    I can’t begin to imagine what social, emotional, and cognitive costs will be borne by these electronically-appeased children. And society.

Commenting has been closed for this post.