Is obesity a reason to avoid joint replacement surgery?

Robert H. Shmerling, MD

Faculty Editor, Harvard Health Publishing

“Come back when you’ve lost 40 pounds.” That’s something obese patients have heard often when being evaluated for a hip or knee replacement for severe arthritis. And sometimes the recommendation is to lose even more — 50, 75, or even 100 pounds… as if that’s an easy or realistic prospect.

As you might expect, patients hearing this often feel disappointed and disheartened. After all, most have already tried hard to lose weight with limited success. Their arthritis pain impairs their ability to exercise, and decreasing activity has contributed to their weight gain. So being told to lose significant weight before they can be considered for joint surgery sounds a lot like being told it’s just not going to happen.

Why should obesity preclude joint surgery?

While the surgeon’s recommendations may be disappointing, the rationale seems sound: people carrying a lot of excess weight have long been considered at higher risk for complications, and less likely to experience the profound pain relief expected from this major operation. Indeed, several studies describe higher rates of infections and dislocations and lower rates of good results after hip or knee replacement among the obese, especially the severely obese.

Importantly, many of these studies are more than a decade old, and newer studies are beginning to paint a different picture. A recent study on the risks and benefits of joint replacement among the obese sheds new — and positive — light on an issue that affects many thousands of people.

A new study suggests that being obese should not preclude joint replacement

Researchers analyzed the results of more than 5,000 people having hip or knee replacement surgery, comparing pain and function before and six months after surgery. Here’s what they found:

  • Those who were the most obese (about 25% of those in the study) had more pain and poorer function prior to surgery than those who were leaner.
  • The amount of functional gain in obese individuals six months after joint replacement was significant, and similar to that experienced by those who were not obese.
  • Pain relief was greater among the most obese than other weight groups. After surgery, pain levels were similar in all weight groups.

The authors conclude that “obesity in itself should not be a deterrent to undergoing total joint replacement to relieve symptoms.” However, the potential for more complications must be considered as well, something this study did not formally examine.

Given the high and rising rates of obesity and arthritis in this country, the results of this study will likely apply to many people. And they suggest that surgeons should change expectations about what surgery has to offer obese individuals with severe arthritis.

The bottom line

While avoiding obesity in the first place is still preferable, there is increasing evidence that the benefits of joint replacement surgery are not limited to those who are lean. If this new research is confirmed by others, we may see fewer obese people turned down for joint replacement surgery in the future.

Follow me on Twitter @RobShmerling

Comments:

  1. Bob

    Very interesting. I would think the more mobile a person is the better chance they have at life. if weight loss prior to surgery is to reduce the risk of the surgery then this has to considered but in the event the weight does not come off then to not operate would leave the person not only in pain but immobile as well and possibly feeling depressed . There seems to be a psychological aspect as well as life style that perhaps needs to be addressed in any event.

  2. azure

    I’d agree with those findings: a friend gained weight in middle age (was overweight, unsure if her BMI ever placed her in obese category) because of a chronic illness that made difficult for her to exercise. Eventually her knees deteriorated to the point where she used a wheelchair for part of her day. Since she’s had both knees replaced and did the hard work of rehab afterwards, she’s able to climb up & down stairs, something she had great difficulty (did not do) for a number of years. She has also lost weight (although primarily due to another health issue, she doesn’t feel much hunger as a result of that health issue and its treatment).

    Her life has improved as a result of knee replacement.

  3. Martin Adam

    Great write-up! Thank you for the post.

Post a Comment:

This blog aims to provide reliable information as well as healthy dialog about the topics covered. We do not provide responses to personal medical concerns nor do we endorse any recommendations offered in the comments. We reserve the right to delete comments for any reason, particularly those that do not relate directly to the contents of this post, are commercial in nature, contain objectionable or inappropriate material, or otherwise violate our Privacy Policy. Promotional URLs will be removed from comments. Comments on this blog do not represent the views of our editors or Harvard University, and have not been checked for accuracy. All comments submitted to this site become the non-exclusive property of Harvard University.