Recent Blog Articles

Heart Health

For the good of your heart: Keep holding the salt

sodium-and-heart-health
July 11, 2016

Disclaimer:

As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review or update on all articles. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.

Comments

Sam
August 14, 2016

I’m gonna increase my salt intake. I drink a lot of water and think I’m peeing all the sodium out.

Francisco
July 24, 2016

Hi
can I put your article on my facebook
thanks

sridevi
July 20, 2016

nice post

Maria Jasmine Freeman
July 20, 2016

V important subject; thanks.
Hypovolemia, one cause being too low sodium intake- triggers vasoconstriction, which on the long run causes structural changes at the renal vessels level, paving the way for-paradoxically- hypertension! Effect of too much salt intake, on the other hand, seems to promote high blood pressure, at least in a certain patient group. With this, the best option as to salt intake, is moderation; the key question remains, what salt intake is moderation?!?

Dr. Ashraf Chaudhry
July 16, 2016

For healthy and long life, we should limit salt as well as sugar in our diets. Sugar is more dangerous than salt and cause of inflammation in our body. Inflammation, we know cause of heart disease, diabetes and cancer. So say goodbye to soda/soft drinks and other sugary beverages.

Dr Sameer Kauchali, Cape Town - Vitamin D- Hormone Foundation of South Africa
July 12, 2016

I believe we have forgotten the role of potassium – it is the relationship between the sodium and potassium levels that determine the BP. If this ratio is skewed then problems arise. Potassium and sodium are cotransported accross the cell membranes of cells.

So if one restricts salt, then it affects the potassium levels as well – this could explain the increased morbidity and moratality in those patients.

Geri L Weber RN,BSN
July 12, 2016

the adulterated salt found in the USA is the worst culprit.It is stripped of ALL beneficial minerals. Add to that the high amount of sodium found in our processed foods and you have a recipe for disaster. Pink Himalayan salt is a HEALTHY (True Salt is another) alternative. In addition, if a moderate amount of of a healthy salt is used in cooking- the food tastes better making addition of more salt at the table unnecessary!!! Wake up folks!!As usual ” the studies” were skewed to support any number of the commercial endeavors that are found in our society!!!

Indu Saxena
July 13, 2016

Dear Dr. Kauchali,

I am grateful to you for pointing out the balance between SODIUM and POTASSIUM that the body’s CONTROL SYSTEM maintains, and that’s what determines cardiovascular health, including blood pressure.

There is a true story I will share – of a senior person who was hospitalized and showed LOW SODIUM in the blood., who already ate salt sparingly, with NO PROCESSED foods in the diet The hospital discharged the patient a day later, saying the diet needs to be LOW in SODIUM due to there being a case of CHF , and reduced kidney function.
The patient went OFF ANY ADDED salt COMPLETELY.
One week later, the patient had to be taken to ER due to repeated throwing up.
The DIAGNOSIS = VERY HIGH POTASSIUM !!

That indicates clearly – that the SODIUM-POTASSIUM balance was disturbed sufficiently by STOPPING added salt to result in an emergency condition.

Your thoughts ?

-Indu

Jan Purcell
July 12, 2016

I believe every thing in moderation. One minute they some thing is bad for you, then later they say it’s good for you.

Khatib
July 12, 2016

Good hear from professionals, and see how knowledge is exchanged.
Keep it up.

Bill Morton
July 11, 2016

There is no way that I will buy into the theory that increased salt consumption will promote better health. Even if you are a vegan or vegetarian, you are still getting plenty of salt in your diet if you refuse to use when cooking, and avoiding it in restaurant and take out foods.

Bob
July 11, 2016

Normally I read a lot of alternative health stuff and compare Harvard newsletter as the standard for conventional medical thinking and see what the difference is. This is a good article and believable on sodium intake than what I have read in alternative articles. Honesty and thoughtful thinking wins out in the long run and establishes a good reputation that readers can follow with some confidence.

shirley sink
July 11, 2016

I am a senior. My blood pressure is always 120/65 give or take 5. My highest pressure ever was 140/82. I had heart stents 13 yrs ago. My blood wk shows I’m on the low end of sodium. I don’t watch my salt intake because I look & feel dehydrated.I drink lots of water. The nite before my last blood work I had a large bowl of salty pop corn. My blood pressure was 114/64. It puzzles me.

Paulo Junior
July 11, 2016

Muito bom!!

Frases de Feliz Aniversário

account user
July 11, 2016

What bunch of dummies. 🙁
One would think they would be embarrassed to create a poor study like that.
We need more intelligent people like engineers in medical schools
rather than the present crew who just memorize everything.

I seem to know more about cardiovascular disease than my cardiologist.
She keeps throwing 25 year-old dogma at me. Doesn’t she read current papers???

Craig Blurton
July 11, 2016

How do you respond to the studies described in this article published in Scientific American in 2011? I think the question is not a clear-cut as you would have us believe.

It’s Time to End the War on Salt, Scientific American, July 8, 2011: Melinda Wenner Moyer.

Jerry Amos
July 11, 2016

We eat mostly whole foods with little processed foods. We don’t add any salt. My blood test shows comfortably mid-range sodiium. We do a little kelp for iodine. Mostly salt is used by Food, Inc. because it is a very cheap spice, who cares about harm.

Sue O
July 11, 2016

My husband and I do not add extra salt to our food. I do add the amount required in recipes. We are also trying to cut our intake of salty processed snacks and eat more fruits and vegetables. I think this is sensible.

Chuck Bluestein
July 11, 2016

There definitely is a flaw but it is not where it is guessed to be. It is right in front of you. I know about from salt levels from people who fast. They consume no salt but have salt levels in their urine that are insanely high. The flaw is that the more sodium that you consume, the less is in your urine.

Salt is not a food and is terrible for health. Who would you guess to have more nicotine in their urine– the person who is chain smoker or the person that does not smoke at all, but just quit smoking.

Robert Bramel
July 11, 2016

Have the authors of this article read the material they reference!? Apparently not. Following the links in this article leads to the NEJM “Urinary Sodium and Potassium Excretion, Mortality, and Cardiovascular Events”. This article is sited as the evidence that elevated sodium is bad, and yet:

“In this study in which sodium intake was estimated on the basis of measured urinary excretion, an estimated sodium intake between 3 g per day and 6 g per day was associated with a lower risk of death and cardiovascular events than was either a higher or lower estimated level of intake.”

Three to six grams per day is best?! From the NEJM? who knew?

This article argues that 3 grams or less is associated with worse outcomes; a position that is consistent with the “awful” Lancet study and quite inconsistent with the 2.3 or 1.5 grams that is supposedly ideal.

Mark Jackman, PhD
July 11, 2016

Nice, clear explanation of the methodological issues behind the headline results. Those headlines were a disservice to the many people who haven’t studied research methodology and end up feeling bewildered by the volatility of findings and recommendations. It was confusing enough to those of us who have studied these issues.

norbert boruett
July 11, 2016

This quiet confusing, nonetheless, more research needs to be done, in the absence of randomization, one has to take the findings with a pinch of salt.

Mariam R
July 11, 2016

Yikes, this is good advice… really tough to take heed of though considering sodium is in EVERYTHING. My cardiologist always encourages me to make the best decisions with my diet, as challenging as it can be sometimes.

Gael C.
July 11, 2016

My mother-in-law, a few years ago in her late 80s (she’s now 92), followed her doctor’s recommendation for a low-salt diet and got very sick when her blood sodium dropped too low. The nephrologist prescribed full-salt Campbell’s chicken noodle soup until she got better and advised her to stop restricting salt in her regular diet. So it can happen that someone can reduce their salt intake too much. Just saying.

Richard H. Serlin
July 11, 2016

So what do you think is too low a sodium level, given that a certain amount of salt is essential for cell function? And for children, crucially with developing bodies and brains, do they need more sodium? You certainly don’t want to be deficient in anything with this development, as important as it is.

Maybe there are serious problems with this Lancet study, but there was a similar JAMA study before it, perhaps they do allude to problems from too little sodium for cell function? In any case, it would be well worth the money to do a new, extremely well devised, extensive study to really resolve these questions.

DPBF
July 11, 2016

Dr. Fisher, with all due respect, your statement, “A wealth of rigorous scientific studies supports a link between excess sodium intake and high blood pressure, heart attacks, and strokes” is categorically false. (Note that epidemiological data present a stark contradiction regarding the relationship between dietary sodium intake and incidence of hypertension in populations. In fact, the complete opposite is borne out by comprehensive examination of the science. To date, the wealth of science does not support the reduction of sodium in the diets of healthy persons. (NB: The assumption is that obesity is not to be considered a state of good health.) For example, an analysis of salt intake and hypertension published in fall, 2010, by Adam Bernstein, PhD, and Walter Willett, MD, PhD, of the Harvard School of Public Health showed sodium consumption in the American diet to be essentially unchanged over more than half a century…yet incidence of hypertension had risen dramatically in the same time period. If hypertension cases have gone up, but salt intake has stayed the same, it’s not the salt. Scientific data to date indicate that only for some 4-10% of persons at most—estimates vary according to studies—would restricting intake of sodium be at least somewhat helpful in controlling blood pressure. But for the 90+% who are perfectly healthy, it would not, and for some populations, such as the elderly, it can even be harmful. Ironically, about 4% of persons in the U.S. are currently living with cancer. As an MD, would you advocate treating every man, woman and child in the country with radiation and chemotherapy “just in case?” After all, cancer kills ten times as many persons as hypertension.

Dr Samir
July 11, 2016

Sir
High blood pressure not caused only from inteacellular at physiological point of view
From sodium as the main cause..
You may get HBP from kidney or from vascular or from psychological factor..or from heart itself

Advise to have balancing food for normal healthy
Life
Plus a check up periodically..
And be practacing some good style in life
Sport..and musical..
Walking with good partner to talk with..
Thanks

Claudia
July 11, 2016

What is the most reliable way for an average person to know what their sodium intake/measurement actually is? I was diagnosed with HYDROPS after having hearing loss and constant aural fullness-sometimes earaches. My ENT recommended a salt reduced diet, no caffeine and vitamins with heavy B-12. Blood pressure 120/70 HR 55. 68 year old female. not obese. Thanks for keeping us informed w/o charging for each report.

Bill
July 11, 2016

I love salt and at 70 my blood pressure is 116/74 which I’m happy with. Heart rate was 58 and 57. I’ve always been active but I would rather cut sugar which I don’t than salt.

Margae
July 11, 2016

Thank you for including the whole article. So nice not to have to buy a booklet to get beyond the headline to the “rest of the story.”

Irene Ippolito
July 11, 2016

I had the same thought.

Terry
July 11, 2016

Amen, to that. The price they ask for their reports is enough to give you High Blood Pressure. lol I can’t afford them.

james wightman
July 11, 2016

What about people like me who eat almost no processed food, live in the desert, participate in endurance sport, and make sure that I drink plenty of water?

My blood pressure is fine and i don’t take medication.

Do you think that I should stop salting my food?

Bill
July 11, 2016

James, good point. I only eat fresh foods, as many years ago someone said “if man made it don’t eat it.” I do eat meat not as much now as when I was younger but only eat fresh cuts

James R
July 11, 2016

My problem with all of this: I have high blood pressure and I have low sodium blood levels. I have removed the water pill from my bp regimen, and I have begun having a glass of v8 or a small dish of cottage cheese daily. I suspect I’d ruled out all salt, but for restaurant dishes, and perhaps it was too much. I’ll be interested to see what my bp and sodium levels are at next doc visit.

Commenting has been closed for this post.