Recent Blog Articles

Harvard Health Blog

Another study shows PSA testing doesn’t save lives

April 07, 2011

Disclaimer:

As a service to our readers, Harvard Health Publishing provides access to our library of archived content. Please note the date of last review or update on all articles. No content on this site, regardless of date, should ever be used as a substitute for direct medical advice from your doctor or other qualified clinician.

Comments

Albert Peckham
June 19, 2014

I was one of the fortunate males to have had a prostate biopsy and found (2012 at 72 y/o) that I had cancer of the prostate. I lived one year with “watch and wait”; the next year another biopsy found that the cancer had attached itself to one of the nerve bundles and I felt it required immediate attention. I found through a lot of research that MDAnderson, out of Texas, has an IMRT program that fitted my needs. After the IMRT program of 42 sessions, my PSA went from 9.5 to 1.4 in one year. Without the PSA tests, I could have been overcome with prostate cancer in less that 5 years.
This doesn’t mean that I’m home w/o prostate cancer, it just means that I’m still here and viable albeit not in the same way I was before the treatments.

Bill Sardi
June 02, 2011

This is the problem with American medicine. In Britain, the PSA test is disregarded. There is considerable criticism now in treating diseases based upon markers. The result is needless treatment. Testing for PSA at all ages would just increase the rate of overtreatment, not prolong survival. Too many men, out of fear, demand treatment that will not save their lives. Patients and their loved ones are deceived by the calendar effect, that earlier detection equates with longer survival. Yes, true, from the date of detection, but the patients are dying on the same calendar day. Any prolongation in survival is imagined. The treatments are largely ineffective and alternatives need to be sought immediately upon confirmed diagnosis rather than after treatments have failed. Some of the most promising are molecular medicine approaches to prostate cancer, which includes natural molecules such as lycopene (tomatoes), resveratrol and quercetin(grapes, red wine), vitamin D (sunlight), vitamin E (tocopherols and tocotrienols), and the trace mineral selenium. There is growing evidence that these molecular approaches also enhance existing treatment, helping overcome treatment resistance and reducing treatment side effects. The prevailing problem is that patients and their loved ones demand something be done and will protest loudly if nothing is done. They will demand insurance pay for treatment regardless of efficacy. The same occurred for bone marrow transplants for breast cancer. Family members would run to the local newspaper to protest that insurance companies were rationing care and not living up to their agreement to pay for treatment. It was all for naught. Doctors share some blame for giving in to patient demands. I know some men who for years have lived with chronic prostatitis and elevated PSA. To biopsy, surgically excise and toxicate is to only provoke localized precancerous tissue into a spreading form of cancer. Hippocrates noted that it was better to leave tumors alone rather than treat. The first goal should be to keep tumors from spreading (metastasizing). Surgical invasion triggers the growth of new blood vessels (angiogenesis) in the wound healing process that can grow tumors. These new blood vessels then create a pathway for tumor cells to travel elsewhere. Surgical removal will still leave a few million tumor cells. Efforts to elevate activity of white blood cells to mop up roaming cancer cells and to inhibit adhesion of tumor cells to the walls of blood vessels would be strategies to prevent metastasis, which is the mortal form of the disease.

Anette
May 07, 2011

I think both doctors and men find PSA generally confusing.
My neighbour who is 65 and has a PSA level of 7has been told he needs to have a biopsy by one doctor but another doctor is telling him level is normal for his age. Both doctors work in the same hospital. Who is right???

Suzanne Rose
May 09, 2011

PSA levels appear to depend partly on age. A PSA of 5 ng/ml might be considered normal for a 73-year-old man, whereas a PSA of 3.9 ng/ml in a 50-year-old man might be a red flag. For that reason, some doctors and researchers advocate adjusting “normal” levels for different age groups. On the other hand, some doctors recommend that the threshold to biopsy be lowered to 2.5 ng/ml for men of any age. (Tradiationally, a biopsy has been recommended for men with PSA levels of 4 ng/ml and higher, though can can change if a man has a family history of prostate cancer.)

One strategy pursued by some men in this situation who are reluctant to have an immediate biopsy is to wait several weeks and then have their PSA checked again. PSA levels can be elevated for reasons that have nothing to do with cancer. The results of the second test may help in making a decision about whether to have a biopsy.

Natalie Amateur
April 29, 2011

To care passionately for another human creature brings always more sorrow than joy.

Kyanna
April 21, 2011

Good point. I hadn’t touhhgt about it quite that way. 🙂

prostate health
April 14, 2011

I have read many negative reviews about PSA testing however I am always wondering why still it is the most common method the health providers are using today. Though I agree with you about its unreliability however I don’t think it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t save lives. I think it had also lives but not everytime it is used. Without PSA test, what could be the other way in diagnosing prostate problem that is most reliable then? http://www.sexualhealthcare.net/

Jesus navarrete
April 08, 2011

PSA is always confusing for patients and even more for doctors, specially the last years.

Tamara Wyman
April 08, 2011

I believe a doctor has a responsibility to avoid making blanket statements that could cost lives. By advocating that PSA testing doesn’t save lives, he is generating a false sense of security for thousands of men who may never know enough to ask for a PSA test after experiencing erectile and urinary symptoms – especially at a young age. If people in responsible positions tell you “you don’t need it” and “that doesn’t happen to men under 50” – you just might believe it…

Jen
April 07, 2011

I am disgusted with this article! I just lost my husband at age 40 to prostate cancer. Yes, that is correct, age 40. He was diagnosed at age 35. After he was diagnosed we later came to find out that he did have a PSA test at age 33 . It was a 2.5 . Yes I understand that it is within “normal” range for a 50 year old but Not a 33 year old!!!! The doctor failed to do a follow up test. 2 years later he was diagnosed with stage 4 prostate cancer. I don’t understand what the big deal is to do a simple blood test!! If he had a follow up PSA maybe he would still be here today and they would have caught it sooner. This disease is attacking men younger and younger everyday. This is not an “old mans disease” anymore!! If a man complains of any symptom related to a prostate issue they should have a PSA done!!!! Oh, and by the way, we sued the doctor who failed to follow up and we WON!!!!!!

Commenting has been closed for this post.

Harvard Health Publishing Logo

Thanks for visiting. Don't miss your FREE gift.

The Best Diets for Cognitive Fitness, is yours absolutely FREE when you sign up to receive Health Alerts from Harvard Medical School

Sign up to get tips for living a healthy lifestyle, with ways to fight inflammation and improve cognitive health, plus the latest advances in preventative medicine, diet and exercise, pain relief, blood pressure and cholesterol management, and more.

Harvard Health Publishing Logo

Health Alerts from Harvard Medical School

Get helpful tips and guidance for everything from fighting inflammation to finding the best diets for weight loss...from exercises to build a stronger core to advice on treating cataracts. PLUS, the latest news on medical advances and breakthroughs from Harvard Medical School experts.

BONUS! Sign up now and
get a FREE copy of the
Best Diets for Cognitive Fitness

Harvard Health Publishing Logo

Stay on top of latest health news from Harvard Medical School.

Plus, get a FREE copy of the Best Diets for Cognitive Fitness.