| |
Perimenopause:
Rocky road to menopause
Symptoms we call “menopausal” often
precede menopause by years.
(This article was first printed in the August
2005 issue of the Harvard Women's Health
Watch. For more information or to order,
please go to www.health.harvard.edu/womens.)
You’re in your 40s, you wake up in a sweat
at night, and your periods are erratic, and often
accompanied by heavy bleeding: Chances are, you’re
going through perimenopause. Many women experience
an array of symptoms as their hormones shift
during the months or years leading up to menopause — that
is, the natural end of menstruation. Menopause
is a point in time, but perimenopause (peri,
Greek for “around” or “near,” +
menopause) is an extended transitional state.
It’s also sometimes referred to as the
menopausal transition, although technically,
the transition ends 12 months earlier than perimenopause
(see “Stages of reproductive aging,” below).
Perimenopause has been variously defined, but
experts generally agree that it begins with irregular
menstrual cycles — courtesy of declining
ovarian function — and ends a year after
the last menstrual period.
Perimenopause varies greatly from one woman
to the next. The average duration is three to
four years, although it can last just a few months
or extend as long as a decade. Some women feel
buffeted by hot flashes and wiped out by heavy
periods; many have no bothersome symptoms. Periods
may end more or less abruptly for some, while
others may menstruate erratically for years.
Fortunately, as knowledge about reproductive
aging has grown, so have the options for treating
some of its more distressing features.
Dance of the hormones
The physical changes of perimenopause are rooted
in hormonal alterations, particularly variations
in the level of circulating estrogen.
During our peak reproductive years, the amount
of estrogen in circulation rises and falls fairly
predictably throughout the menstrual cycle. Estrogen
levels are largely controlled by two hormones,
follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing
hormone (LH). FSH stimulates the follicles — the
fluid-filled sacs in the ovaries that contain
the eggs — to produce estrogen. When estrogen
reaches a certain level, the brain signals the
pituitary to turn off the FSH and produce a surge
of LH. This in turn stimulates the ovary to release
the egg from its follicle (ovulation). The leftover
follicle produces progesterone, in addition to
estrogen, in preparation for pregnancy. As these
hormone levels rise, the levels of FSH and LH
drop. If pregnancy doesn’t occur, progesterone
falls, menstruation takes place, and the cycle
begins again.
Talk about
hot … flashes that is
Most women don’t expect to have
hot flashes until menopause, so it can
be a big surprise when they show up earlier,
during perimenopause. Hot flashes — sometimes
called hot flushes and given the scientific
name of vasomotor symptoms — are
the most commonly reported symptom of perimenopause.
They’re also a regular feature of
sudden menopause due to surgery or treatment
with certain medications, such as chemotherapy
drugs.
Hot flashes tend to come on rapidly and
can last from one to five minutes. They
range in severity from a fleeting sense
of warmth to a feeling of being consumed
by fire “from the inside out.” A
major hot flash can induce facial and upper-body
flushing, sweating, chills, and sometimes
confusion. Having one of these at an inconvenient
time (such as during a speech, job interview,
or romantic interlude) can be quite disconcerting.
Hot flash frequency varies widely. Some
women have a few over the course of a week;
others may experience 10 or more in the
daytime, plus some at night.
Most American women have hot flashes around
the time of menopause, but studies of other
cultures suggest this experience is not
universal. Far fewer Japanese, Korean,
and Southeast Asian women report having
hot flashes. In Mexico’s Yucatan
peninsula, women appear not to have any
at all. These differences may reflect cultural
variations in perceptions, semantics, and
lifestyle factors, such as diet.
Although the physiology of hot flashes
has been studied for more than 30 years,
no one is certain why or how they occur.
Estrogen is involved — if it weren’t,
estrogen therapy wouldn’t relieve
vasomotor symptoms as well as it does — but
it’s not the whole story. For example,
researchers have found no differences in
estrogen levels in women who have hot flash
symptoms and those who don’t. A better
understanding of the causes of hot flashes
could open the way to new, nonhormonal
treatments. Hormone therapy quells hot
flashes, but it’s not risk-free.
One line of inquiry has focused on why
some women have hot flashes and others
don’t. An intriguing explanation
has emerged, thanks largely to research
led by Wayne State University School of
Medicine scientist Robert R. Freedman,
who has studied hot flashes for 25 years.
He and his colleagues have measured skin
temperature, blood flow, and skin conductance
(an electrical measure of sweating) in
menopausal women before, during, and after
hot flashes. They’ve asked subjects
to wear monitors to collect hot flash data,
swallow radiotelemetry pills to measure
core body temperatures, and spend nights
in a sleep laboratory to have their hot
flashes tracked.
Freedman has found that women who have
hot flashes have a lower tolerance for
small increases in the body’s core
(innermost) temperature than women who
don’t have hot flashes. The body
tries to maintain its core temperature
within a comfortable “thermoneutral
zone.” When our core temperature
rises above the zone’s upper threshold,
we sweat; when it drops below the lower
threshold, we shiver. Women who don’t
have hot flashes have a thermoneutral zone
of several tenths of a degree centigrade.
But in women with hot flashes, this thermoneutral
zone is so narrow, it’s “virtually
nonexistent,” says Freedman (see
illustration). As a result, small variations
in core body temperature — by as
little as one-tenth of a degree centigrade — that
don’t trouble some women trigger
hot flashes (and chills) in others.

Source: Adapted from Freedman, RR. Seminars
in Reproductive Medicine 2005; 23
(2): 117-125.
What causes the thermoneutral zone to
narrow? One idea is that elevated levels
of the brain chemical norepinephrine are
involved. Norepinephrine has been shown
to reduce the thermoneutral zone in animals.
Conversely, the drug clonidine, which lowers
norepinephrine, widens the zone in women
with hot flashes. So do estrogen and certain
antidepressants, though scientists still
don’t understand all the mechanisms.
Because hot flashes are triggered by elevations
in core body temperature, the first-line
strategy for avoiding them is keeping cool:
Drink cold beverages and avoid hot ones,
use fans and air conditioners, and dress
in layers. Another nondrug technique is
paced respiration. In controlled studies,
Dr. Freedman has shown that paced respiration
can reduce hot flash frequency by about
50%. Women in these studies were trained
to take slow, deep, full breaths — expanding
and contracting the abdomen gently while
inhaling and exhaling — at a rate
of about six to eight breaths per minute.
One of the best ways to learn paced respiration
is by taking a yoga class, then practicing
this technique twice a day for 15 minutes.
You can also use paced respiration whenever
you feel a hot flash coming on. |
By our late 30s, we don’t produce as much
progesterone. The number and quality of follicles
also diminishes, causing a decline in estrogen
production and fewer ovulations. As a result,
by our 40s, cycle length and menstrual flow may
vary and periods may become irregular. Estrogen
may drop precipitously or spike higher than normal.
Over time, FSH levels rise in a vain attempt
to prod the ovaries into producing more estrogen.
Although a high FSH can be a sign that perimenopause
has begun, a single FSH reading isn’t a
reliable indicator because day-to-day hormone
levels can fluctuate dramatically (see middle
graphic, below).

By comparison with the regularity of hormone
levels before perimenopause (top graph)
and their relative quiescence after it
(bottom graph), the course of one perimenopausal
woman’s hormones over a six-month
period (middle graph) looks like Mr. Toad’s
Wild Ride. Not all women’s hormones
are so adventurous. |
Perimenopausal symptoms
It can be difficult to distinguish the hormonally
based symptoms of perimenopause from more general
changes due to aging or common midlife events — such
as children leaving home, changes in relationships
or careers, or the death or illness of parents.
Given the range of women’s experience of
perimenopause, it’s unlikely that symptoms
depend on hormonal fluctuations alone.
- Hot flashes and night sweats. An
estimated 35%–50% of perimenopausal women
suffer sudden waves of body heat with sweating
and flushing that last 5–10 minutes,
often at night as well as during the day. They
typically begin in the scalp, face, neck, or
chest and can differ dramatically among women
who have them; some women feel only slightly
warm, while others end up wringing wet. Hot
flashes often continue for a year or two after
menopause. In up to 10% of women, they persist
for years beyond that.
The Study of Women’s Health Across the
Nation, which surveyed almost 15,000 women
in the United States, found that, on average,
African American women had more hot flashes
than white women, and Asian women had the fewest
of all ethnic groups surveyed. Research has
also found that hot flashes are associated
with greater body weight, smoking, and stress.
- Vaginal dryness. During
late perimenopause, falling estrogen levels
can cause vaginal tissue to become thinner
and drier. Vaginal dryness (which usually becomes
even worse after menopause) can cause itching
and irritation. It may also be a source of
pain during intercourse, contributing to a
decline in sexual desire at midlife.
- Uterine bleeding problems. With
less progesterone to regulate the growth of
the endometrium, the uterine lining may become
thicker before it’s shed, resulting in
very heavy periods. Also, fibroids (benign
tumors of the uterine wall) and endometriosis
(the migration of endometrial tissue to other
pelvic structures), both of which are fueled
by estrogen, may become more troublesome.
- Sleep disturbances. Data
presented at a March 2005 NIH conference on
managing menopausal symptoms suggest that about
40% of perimenopausal women have sleep problems.
Some studies have shown a relationship between
night sweats and disrupted sleep; others have
not. The problem is too complex to blame on
hormone oscillations alone. Sleep cycles change
as we age, and insomnia is a common age-related
complaint in both sexes.
- Mood symptoms. Estimates
put the number of women who experience mood
symptoms during perimenopause at 10%–20%.
Some studies have linked estrogen to depression
during the menopausal transition, but there’s
no proof that depression in women at midlife
reflects declining hormone levels. In fact,
women actually have a lower rate of depression
after age 45 than before. Menopause-related
hormone changes are also unlikely to make women
anxious or chronically irritable, although
the unpredictability of perimenopause can be
stressful and provoke some episodes of irritability.
Also, some women may be more vulnerable than
others to hormone-related mood changes. The
2005 NIH conference concluded that the best
predictors of mood symptoms at midlife are
life stress, poor overall health, and a history
of depression.
- Other problems. Many
women complain of short-term memory problems
and difficulty concentrating during the menopausal
transition. Although estrogen and progesterone
are players in maintaining brain function,
there’s too little information to separate
the effects of aging and psychosocial factors
from those related to hormone changes.
What to do about symptoms
Several treatments have been studied for managing
perimenopausal symptoms. Complementary therapies
are also available, but research on them is limited
and the results are inconsistent.
- Vasomotor symptoms. The
first rule is to avoid possible triggers of
hot flashes, which include warm air temperatures,
hot beverages, and spicy foods. You know your
triggers best. Dress in layers so you can take
off clothes as needed. There’s clear
evidence that paced respiration, a deep breathing
technique, helps alleviate hot flashes (see
sidebar story about hot flashes).
The most effective treatment for severe hot
flashes and night sweats is estrogen. Unless
you’ve had a hysterectomy, you’ll
also need to take a progestin to reduce the
risk of developing endometrial cancer. Low-dose
estrogen by pill or patch — for example,
doses that are less than or equal to 0.3 milligrams
(mg) conjugated equine estrogen, 0.5 mg oral
micronized estradiol, 25 micrograms (mcg) transdermal
(patch) estradiol, or 2.5 mcg ethinyl estradiol — works
for many women. Other low-dose estradiol-based
products include a skin lotion applied to the
legs (Estrasorb) and a gel applied to the arms
(EstroGel), both available by prescription.
The long-term risks of low-dose estrogen aren’t
known.

If you need contraception and don’t smoke,
you can take low-dose birth control pills until
menopause (see “Irregular periods and
heavy bleeding”). Another advantage of
these pills is that they regulate your menses
and suppress the erratic hormonal ups and downs
of perimenopause; some women report feeling
more even-tempered while taking them. Progestins
taken alone, such as Megace and Depo-Provera,
have been shown to reduce hot flashes, but
their safety for this purpose has not been
tested.
Women with severe hot flashes who don’t
want or can’t take a hormonal therapy
may get some relief from newer antidepressants
such as Effexor (venlafaxine) or certain selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), for
example, Prozac (fluoxetine) and Paxil (paroxetine);
the epilepsy drug Neurontin (gabapentin); or
clonidine, a blood pressure drug. Some of these
medications have side effects that may limit
their usefulness. Also, some SSRIs can interfere
with the metabolism of tamoxifen in certain
women.
Information on the value of nutritional supplements
is mixed. Although the NIH is studying black
cohosh, results from research on the possible
benefits of this herb, isoflavones, and other
phytoestrogens have been inconsistent as of
summer 2005, in part because of varying doses
and preparations. Studies of evening primrose
oil, dong quai, ginseng, red clover, acupuncture,
and vitamin E have shown little or no benefit
in alleviating hot flashes. So-called bioidentical
hormones that are compounded individually (sometimes
based on blood or salivary tests of hormone
levels) may help, just as FDA-approved products
do, but their safety and effectiveness haven’t
been well-studied.
- Irregular periods and heavy bleeding. If
you have irregular bleeding and don’t
want to become pregnant, low-dose birth control
pills are a good choice. By suppressing ovulation,
they modulate menstrual flow, regulate periods,
and stabilize endometriosis. They also protect
against endometrial and ovarian cancers, stave
off hot flashes, reduce vaginal dryness, and
prevent bone loss. If you have abnormal bleeding,
such as daily or very heavy bleeding, see your
gynecologist.
Oral contraceptives can be taken until menopause.
To help determine whether you’ve reached
menopause, your clinician may order a blood
test of your FSH level, taken after seven days
off the pill. But the only wholly reliable
measure is 12 months off hormones without a
menstrual period.
- Vaginal dryness. Low-dose
contraceptives or vaginal estrogen (in a cream,
ring, tablet, or gel) can help relieve vaginal
dryness, but hormonal treatment is not the
only approach. Vaginal moisturizers such as
Replens, applied twice weekly, increase vaginal
moisture, elasticity, and acidity. Continued
sexual activity also seems to improve vaginal
tone and helps maintain the acidic environment
that protects it against infections. Lubricants
such as K-Y Jelly, Astroglide, and K-Y Silk-E
can make intercourse less painful.
(This article was first printed in the August
2005 issue of the Harvard Women's Health
Watch. For more information or to order,
please go to www.health.harvard.edu/womens.)
|
|