Reconsidering the placebo response
Acupuncture studies provide new insights into how treatment context affects outcomes.
In scientific studies, the term placebo usually refers to an inert pill or procedure that serves as a comparison to an active intervention (typically a drug or psychotherapy). Now a handful of acupuncture studies not only provides additional evidence that a placebo itself can have dramatic impact on illness, but also suggest that the context in which an intervention takes place can bolster the placebo response.
The nature of the placebo response — and whether it even exists — has been the subject of scientific discussion for decades. In a 1955 paper, pioneering anesthesiologist Dr. Henry K. Beecher famously described the placebo response as powerful. Nearly a half-century later, a review published by the prestigious Cochrane Collaboration concluded instead that the placebo might be powerless. More recently, the Cochrane reviewers conducted another analysis and reached a middle ground, concluding that for some clinical conditions — particularly pain and nausea — placebos may confer symptom alleviation, while in other situations they do not.