This is your brain on alcohol

Beverly Merz
Beverly Merz, Executive Editor, Harvard Women's Health Watch

It’s no secret that alcohol affects our brains, and most moderate drinkers like the way it makes them feel — happier, less stressed, more sociable. Science has verified alcohol’s feel-good effect; PET scans have shown that alcohol releases endorphins (the “pleasure hormones”) which bind to opiate receptors in the brain. Although excessive drinking is linked to an increased risk of dementia, decades of observational studies have indicated that moderate drinking — defined as no more than one drink a day for women and two for men — has few ill effects. (A drink equals 1.5 ounces of 80-proof spirits, 5 ounces of wine, or 12 ounces of beer.) However, a recent British study seems to have bad news for moderate drinkers, indicating that even moderate drinking is associated with shrinkage in areas of the brain involved in cognition and learning.

What the study said

A team of researchers from University of Oxford looked at data from 424 men and 103 women who are participating in the 10,000-person Whitehall Study, an ongoing investigation of the relationship of lifestyle and health among British civil servants. At the beginning of the study in 1985, all of the participants were healthy and none were dependent on alcohol. Over the next 30 years, the participants answered detailed questions about their alcohol intake and took tests to measure memory, reasoning, and verbal skills. They underwent brain imaging with MRI at the end of the study.

When the team analyzed the questionnaires, the cognitive test scores, and the MRI scans, they found that the amount of shrinkage in the hippocampus — the brain area associated with memory and reasoning — was related to the amount people drank. Those who had the equivalent of four or more drinks a day had almost six times the risk of hippocampal shrinkage as did nondrinkers, while moderate drinkers had three times the risk. However, the only link between drinking and cognitive performance was that heavy drinkers had a more rapid decline in the ability to name as many words beginning with a specific letter as possible within a minute.

What does this mean?

The study results don’t come as news to Dr. Kenneth J. Mukamal, associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School. Dr. Mukamal and his colleagues reported similar findings in 2001. His team studied 3,376 men and women who were enrolled in the Cardiovascular Heart Study and who had also undergone MRI scans and had reported their alcohol consumption. The Harvard researchers also found that brain volume shrank in proportion to alcohol consumed, and that atrophy (shrinkage) was greater even in light and moderate drinkers than in teetotalers.

Yet the meaning of the MRI scans is still far from clear, Dr. Mukamal says. “There’s a great deal of doubt about whether the atrophy seen on MRI is due to loss of brain cells or to fluid shifts within the brain.” He explains that this type of atrophy shows major improvements within weeks when alcoholics stop drinking, which wouldn’t be the case if it were caused by brain cell death. “The study offers little indication of whether moderate drinking is truly good, bad, or indifferent for long-term brain health,” he says.

What should you do?

If you’re a moderate or light drinker trying to decide whether to cut back for health reasons, you probably want to consider a variety of factors:

  • Moderate drinking still seems to be good for your heart. More than 100 observational studies have linked moderate drinking to a reduced risk of heart attack, ischemic (clot-caused) stroke, peripheral vascular disease, sudden cardiac death, and death from all cardiovascular causes.
  • Moderate drinking has also been associated with a lower risk of gallstones and diabetes.
  • For women, even moderate drinking can increase the risk of breast cancer. If you’re a woman at average risk, a drink per day can increase your lifetime risk of breast cancer from 8.25% to 8.8%
  • The social and psychological benefits of moderate alcohol consumption. One thing health statistics haven’t measured is the enjoyment of moderate drinking. It is fine to enjoy a glass of wine as the perfect accompaniment to a good dinner, or celebrate a happy occasion with a cocktail with friends.

Related Information: Eat, Drink, and Be Healthy

Comments:

  1. Beth Baiter

    Why is non-alcoholic wine not sold in bars and restaurants and most liquor stores? There are acceptable brands and should be sold especially in places where non-alcoholic beer is available.

  2. Alison

    How arrogant of you to post recommendations for women in general, half the sky?, based on just about 100 women studied.

    Versus 424 men. How can you post this in sincerity?

    Is there any ascertainment of the women’s cognition levels before the test started? How can you possibly know what they do or do not remember later? Are these women who have learned to retain information for any length of time?

    It is a shame you attempt to draw conclusions from such shallow research.

  3. Charlotte

    I rarely drink but a glass of good organic Wine preferably and only weekends. It is really difficult to go into a bar or restaurant and not ask for alcohol – everyone thinks you are weird if you don’t – but so I ‘cheat’ Sometimes instead of taking tea (love The way Japanese drink tea to all meals and occasions) then I have The waiter pour sparkling water in a glass with a straw, ice and lime – or thank god for the non-alcoholic drinks where no-one knows either. I wish though it would be much more socially acceptable and cool even, to not drink. I see Vitamin Well driving some nice Social media content of non-alcoholic and trying to make it if not hip then totally ok.

  4. sarah

    This is a great opportunity to be conservative! Don’t drink! However, it’s easy to understand why people do; and some people really can handle it so much better than others! I would like to know more about why that is true since I in some cases know a lot about their other habits. And there’s so much money in alcohol it’s truly sad.

  5. Mo

    So is smoking and I’d rather see NO SMOKING globally in favor of “mild/social alcohol”.

  6. Catherine Polumbus

    Im thinking I’d like to see a study that measures the consumption of sugar or oil associated with brain function. Could be worse things out there.

  7. Jim

    Amen Steven. Also, to say that alcohol makes you happier seems irresponsible to me. Alcohol is a depressant. While in the short term you may feel euphoria, over the long term it induces depression and sadness. It’s time to stop glorifying alcohol. It’s a drug, a depressant, and is not healthy for you. This whole “good in moderation” craziness needs to stop. When you dig a little deeper all of these good in moderation reports end up being sponsored by the alcohol industry to keep everyone addicted.

  8. Steven Elliott

    I always read anything about alcohol suspiciously because the stance on it changes regularly. At the end of the day, however, alcohol is a recognized toxin as are its byproducts. Acetaldehyde, for instance, is a known carcinogen so I don’t understand how a substance that causes cancer and shrinks the brain can also be recommended in moderation. It also damages the kidneys, liver and affects sleep adversely. I think if we are looking for something that can help the heart, perhaps diet and exercise should be looked at. Researching alcohol has to be infuriating because almost nobody is truthful in their reporting of it. With the new information citing brain shrinkage, I don’t see the benefit of it.

    • Biren

      Agree one hundred percent

    • Celine Brabo

      Thank you so much for saying that, Steven. I completely agree with you. And I would add that the negative effects of moderate alcohol consumption on family relationships are often overlooked.

    • AP

      Alcohol has been “acceptable” for way too long. It has no benefits! Brain shrinkage, cancer, addiction, ruins relationships, families and deaths….lets wake up and realize this is not ok.

      • Dave

        No benefits? Did you not read the article? Good for the heart, lower risk of gallstones and diabetes, and enjoyment in social settings. Feel free to have your opinions on things, but don’t make a comment that contradicts the very article you are commenting on!

Post a Comment:

This blog aims to provide reliable information as well as healthy dialog about the topics covered. We reserve the right to delete comments for any reason, particularly those that do not relate directly to the contents of this post, are commercial in nature, contain objectionable or inappropriate material, or otherwise violate our Privacy Policy. Promotional URLs will be removed from comments. Comments on this blog do not represent the views of our editors or Harvard University, and have not been checked for accuracy. All comments submitted to this site become the non-exclusive property of Harvard University.