Howard LeWine, M.D.

Doctor’s warning may prompt some to give up driving

In a car culture like ours, giving up the car keys can be a wrenching decision. Some see it as a loss of independence. For others, especially those who live in areas with poor public transportation, not driving makes it difficult to shop for groceries or see friends. But the fact is that some older people need to make that decision. Pleas from family members can sometimes do the trick. A special article in this week’s New England Journal of Medicine suggests that advice from a doctor can also help people who shouldn’t be behind the wheel any longer stop driving.

A Canadian team looked at the health records of more than 100,000 men and women who had been warned by a doctor that they were potentially unfit to drive. Their rate of auto accidents was 45% lower in the year after the warning than in the three years before it. The researchers couldn’t tell whether this was because the people drove less after the warning, or drove more carefully.

There was a downside to the advice, though. People who received a “stop driving” warning were more likely to have been treated afterward for depression, and some stopped seeing the doctor who gave the warning.

Who should stop?

A big question that the NEJM article can’t answer is: Who should get a warning about driving?

There are no federal guidelines regarding who can drive. This has always been left up to each state. Rules about reporting potentially impaired drivers differ from state to state, too. Here are some warning signs from AARP indicating that you or someone you know should limit their driving or stop altogether:

  • Almost crashing, with frequent “close calls”
  • Finding dents and scrapes on the car, fences, mailboxes, garage doors, curbs, etc.
  • Getting lost, especially in familiar locations
  • Having trouble seeing or following traffic signals, road signs, and pavement markings
  • Having trouble moving your foot from the gas to the brake pedal, or confusing the two pedals

(You can read the full list in the AARP article “10 Signs That it’s Time to Limit or Stop Driving“)

Driver safety

No matter what your situation or age, there are things you can do to decrease your risk of a car crash.

Eliminate blind spots. Take time before you drive to make sure your rear-view and side mirrors are adjusted to minimize blind spots. Whenever you change lanes, check the mirrors and glance back quickly to be sure no car is hiding in a blind spot.

Be honest about how well you can see. If your vision is even a little blurry, get it checked. If you need glasses or contacts, always wear them when driving.

Don’t accept dozing off at the wheel as just being tired. If you are often drowsy and fall asleep easily during the day, you may have sleep apnea. (Loud snoring with breath-holding and gasps in between is another clue.) Talk with your doctor about that possibility. Avoid long periods of driving after dark or after a big meal. If you feel drowsy while driving, find a safe spot to pull off the road and take a nap. Even 15 to 20 minutes can make a big difference in your alertness.

If you take medications that make you sleepy, consider changing the timing. If you know you will need to drive at certain times, adjust your medicine schedule so that any drowsiness wears off before you drive.

Be honest with your doctor. He or she wants to help keep you safe and not hurt others. In most situations, your doctor can’t stop you from driving. In fact, there’s no way to enforce a doctor’s advice not to drive. But share with your doctor any concerns you have about near misses on the road. That may lead to some advice that can help you be a safer driver. If you are a family member worried about the driving skills of a parent or other relative, go with him or her to the next doctor visit to discuss driving.

Sadly, many people finally stop driving after they’ve crashed, or hurt someone. This is definitely a situation where “better safe than sorry” should rule.

Comments:

  1. Matt Davis

    This is also the season where most drivers get into fender benders with their garages, resulting in a completely broken garage door. It is understandable that people rarely look for blind spots while pulling out of their driveway.

  2. Alec

    After doctor reported in regards to stop driving to many individuals who are not suitable for driving a miracle change notice in the roads of America where accidents and fatal crashes are found 45% less.

    Really these acts are helps more to save their lives might be it is funny but definitely insufficient knowledge on driving can brings severe damages.

  3. Aelicia

    Driving is absolutely a privilege. For many people the thought of them giving up their freedom of local travel is unimaginable. One should consider not only their health but the lives of the public if they feel their driving abilities are even slightly compromised.
    - Aelicia

  4. Gerry

    how much time should I wait to drive if I am recovering from lower back surgery?

  5. Henaty

    I also would like in my country, when drive fast what mentality work?

  6. george

    I had stiffness in my shoulder which always made driving difficult for me and escaped accidents many times. But my physical therapy assistant adviced me a set of exercises and now I don’t face any problem

  7. Katherine

    I’d say driving is not just a privilege but it also has a large amount of social responsibility on top of the driver’s shoulders…Every driver should have this in mind.
    Katherine

  8. Ebo

    Now, this is interesting, in my country, nobody was asked doctors opinions to get a driving license

  9. Mikey Eves

    Aug. 29, 2012, senior driver Preston Carter, 100, drove his car onto a sidewalk and plowed into a group of parents and children outside an elementary school. Nine children and two adults were injured in the wreck.

    This is only going to get worse. More baby boomers are entering the senior world every day. There is no upper age limit for driving a car in California. At the end of last year, 71,111 people 90 or older were licensed to drive in the state.

    Two years ago while on vacation we were in Utah visiting the parks. We had just eaten at a restaurant in bryce canyon and came across a horrible accident caused from the driver having a stroke while driving. There were 3 fatalities in the car. It could have been much worse.

  10. John

    Share with your doctor any concerns you have about driving